35 books finished in 2011

20110814-IMG_0815
Mockingjay (The Hunger Games, Book 3)

I’m going to say it. This book was a bit of a disappointment.

Though, I’m still trying to figure out why, exactly, it felt that way.

Part of the problem might have been that I had run out of emotional energy by this book. Or that there was no calm at the end of the second book in the series, so I was forced right back into the action…but then spent a lot of time waiting, with Katniss, for the world to end…or change forever.

Also, I feel like there were many missed opportunities for emotional growth. Katniss did learn and grow in a few ways, but there were so many honest and obvious examples of emotional immaturity throughout the trilogy, and I would have loved to see Katniss grapple with more of them. (I am incredibly invested in the emotional health of my fictional literary characters, y’all.) Of course, she was only a teenager, and I guess I shouldn’t be so hard on her, since she managed to free humanity from evil oppression.

There were two plot points that I really enjoyed – which I thought were particularly great additions to Young Adult fiction, and which I would have loved to see fleshed out even more:
1. Katniss couldn’t be “groomed” for celebrity. Every time they tried to coach her, or give her a script, she would be awkward and unconvincing. But whenever she was put in a stressful situation and her instincts took over, she won over the whole country. I love seeing these genuine, unfiltered emotions. Of course, the other side of that coin was shown in the many times she acted against instruction and/or bucked authority.
2. The huge disconnect between Katniss’s opinion of herself and the way others viewed her. This…everyone deals with this, right? It felt so universal to me, and the guilt she was feeling over all of these factors which were actually out of her control. I wished there had been a bit more time spent on correcting these notions, but I think it was obvious to the reader that Katniss was wrong about herself…and I hope they realize the ways this might apply to their lives as well.

So, in summary, it sounds like I’d like to conduct a group therapy book club using this trilogy. Who’s in?

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “35 books finished in 2011

  1. Okay. Okay, I agree with these things. I did really enjoy the series, though. And, in fact, I liked Mockingjay the best. But I realize I’m in the minority there. It does have its slow moments, but I think the truth is that I don’t actually enjoy reading about the Games, so of course book three works for me the best. (How can you like the Hunger Games if you don’t enjoy reading about the games?? I don’t know.) And darnit, I just really enjoyed these books for the plot and the romance. Embarrassing.

    Agreed on Katniss’s character: she grew in some ways I appreciated, but there could have been much more.

    Have you read Veronica Roth’s Divergent? I’m curious what your response would be . . .

  2. Not embarrassing! I could probably talk for hours about whether I’m on Team Gale, Team Peeta, or Team Katniss Needs To Take A Break From Boys.

    Perhaps my bigger complaint with this trilogy is that it was too short? I would have liked to see the current story stretched over more books.

    Don’t have Divergent yet. It’s on my list. I think I’m waiting for the whole trilogy to come out so I can read them in one day.

  3. Pingback: 9 books finished in 2012: Removed (draft) | these are the thoughts that fall out of my head

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s